
Climate Policy 21(5), 2021, pp. 699-717
Climate Policy, Taylor & Francis
Negative emissions technologies appear in almost every scenario that meets the Paris goal. How to account for them is still disputed. Matthew Brander and his team at the University of Edinburgh structure the debate on the basis of a systematic literature review.
Authors / institution
Matthew Brander, Francisco Ascui, Vivian Scott, Simon Tett · University of Edinburgh
Published
2021
Five accounting issues
The study distinguishes five topics: system-wide changes in emissions and removals, non-permanence, whether overshoot followed by removal is equivalent to no overshoot, accounting for incentives for negative emissions, and the timing of emissions and removals. For each topic the authors propose solutions or point to open research questions.
Carbon accounting methods should follow a 'reality principle' to report emissions and removals when and where they actually occur.
The right method for the purpose
A central conclusion is that each purpose needs its own method. Decisions on deploying or incentivising negative emissions call for consequential methods that capture all changes in the wider system. Attributional methods suit static descriptions of possible net zero worlds.
How Timber Carbon sees it
Permanence, baseline and timing are also the core questions of any accounting for timber buildings. Timber Carbon deducts the baseline and the production and construction emissions from the CO₂ held in the timber and issues credits only once a building is completed. Details are on the Technology page.
Full reference: Brander, M., Ascui, F., Scott, V., & Tett, S. (2021). Carbon accounting for negative emissions technologies. Climate Policy, 21(5), 699-717. Published online 3 February 2021.
Topics


