
MSCI ESG Research, September 2024
MSCI ESG Research
Do companies buy carbon credits to avoid cutting their own emissions? MSCI ESG Research examined this for the constituents of the MSCI ACWI Investable Markets Index between 2017 and 2022.
Authors / institution
MSCI ESG Research · MSCI Carbon Markets (vormals Trove Research)
Published
2024
Faster reductions among credit users
Only 14 per cent of index constituents used carbon credits between 2017 and 2022, and 11 per cent were material users. For material users, the median credit use amounted to around 13 per cent of Scope 1 and 2 emissions.
The 624 material users reduced their absolute Scope 1 and 2 emissions by 3.6 per cent per year, compared with 1.5 per cent for 2041 non-users. 75 per cent of users cut emissions in absolute terms, against 60 per cent of non-users. Users were also more likely to have a climate target, 92 versus 52 per cent, and in most sectors earned a larger share of revenue from low-carbon activities.
These findings contradict the notion that companies have used carbon credits as an alternative to investing in climate-mitigation activities within their own value chains.
Limits of the analysis
The results are statistically significant across regions and in six out of eleven sectors. The study does not establish causality. It builds on an earlier analysis by Trove Research, which MSCI acquired in November 2023.
How Timber Carbon sees it
The study supports the view that credits complement companies' own reductions. Residual emissions call for durable removals. Companies can purchase the carbon removed by timber buildings as Timber Carbon Removal Credits.
Full reference: MSCI ESG Research (2024). Corporate Emissions Performance and the Use of Carbon Credits. September 2024.
Topics


