
CRETA for the European Commission (DG CLIMA), October 2023
Europäische Kommission, DG CLIMA
Under the EU Carbon Removal Certification Framework (CRCF), buildings are also to be recognised as carbon sinks. Commissioned by the Directorate-General for Climate Action, Partners for Innovation and Wageningen University assessed existing methodologies against the quality criteria of the proposed regulation.
Authors / institution
CRETA-Konsortium: Partners for Innovation · Wageningen University and Research · im Auftrag der Europäischen Kommission (DG CLIMA)
Published
2023
18 methodologies compared
The review draws on a survey of methodology developers and operators in summer 2023 and on 18 methodologies collected by DG CLIMA and CRETA. It checks the four QU.A.L.ITY criteria: quantification, additionality, long-term duration and sustainability. The net benefit is calculated as the project's removals minus the baseline and any additional emissions.
Additionality is mostly handled through eligibility rules. Four methodologies use standardised baselines, and one assumes additionality for biobased materials as long as their market share stays below a threshold. Most methodologies set no fixed certification period; one expires on 31 December 2030.
Overall, it has been found that each of the methodologies contains elements that, when combined, would present a methodology that matches the QU.A.L.ITY criteria.
The Timber Finance Initiative among the developers
The report names the Timber Finance Initiative in Switzerland and the Dutch Stichting Nationale Koolstofmarkt as developers of methodologies that were not yet published at the time and therefore not part of the analysis.
How Timber Carbon sees it
The report is part of the groundwork for EU rules on certifying carbon in buildings. Timber Carbon, launched in 2026 as a spin-off of Timber Finance, has developed the methodology mentioned further. The Technology page shows how it now handles baseline, permanence and co-benefits.
Full reference: CRETA (Partners for Innovation & Wageningen University and Research) (2023). Review of certification methodologies for long-term biogenic carbon storage in buildings. Carbon Removals Expert Group, Technical Assistance, commissioned by DG CLIMA, 13 October 2023.
Topics


