
Energy & Environmental Science 12 (2019), pp. 1210-1218. Open access, CC BY 3.0
Energy & Environmental Science, Royal Society of Chemistry
Negative emission technologies are seen by some as a saviour and by others as a false idol. Samantha Tanzer and Andrea Ramírez of TU Delft show that the term itself is used inconsistently and that system boundaries determine the result.
Authors / institution
Samantha Eleanor Tanzer, Andrea Ramírez · TU Delft
Published
2019
Inconsistent definitions
The authors reviewed 286 peer-reviewed studies from 2014 to 2018. About half define the term explicitly. Of these, 50 per cent mention removal of greenhouse gases from the atmosphere, 29 per cent mention keeping them out of it, and only 20 per cent specify that this must be permanent. Only five studies explicitly require emissions from the entire life cycle to be counted.
A worked example shows the consequences: for a steel mill using BECCS, the result ranges from 1.2 tonnes of CO₂ removed to 1.2 tonnes emitted, depending on the system boundary. Indirect land-use change can cancel the removal entirely.
A negative emission technology should physically remove greenhouse gases from the atmosphere, keep them out permanently, account for upstream and downstream emissions, and remove more than it emits.
Avoided emissions are not removals
Some life cycle assessments label avoided emissions as negative emissions. The authors point out that these are not physical removals. For biomass-based methods, the result depends on the carbon balance of the biomass, land-use change, energy sources and how the accounting is done.
How Timber Carbon sees it
The four criteria apply to timber construction too. Timber Carbon credits only carbon physically held in the structure, deducts production and construction emissions, and reports avoided emissions separately as a co-benefit. Details on the Technology page.
Full reference: Tanzer, S. E., & Ramírez, A. (2019). When are negative emissions negative emissions? Energy & Environmental Science, 12, 1210-1218. Open access under CC BY 3.0.
Topics


